Skip to main content
⚠️ IMPORTANT — PLEASE READ Our website uses stock/representative images. Images may show a 1st Edition stamp even when the card listed for sale is NOT 1st Edition. Please rely on the written product title and description—not the stock image—to determine the edition, variant, & condition being sold.
Black Hills Card Shop

Sell your cards to us

Get a quote in seconds. Pick cash or store credit.

How selling to us works

  1. Search what we are buying

    Find your cards by name, set, or SKU. Pick the game to see what we want right now.

  2. Lock in cash or credit

    See our live buy price for each condition. Choose cash or take extra in store credit, then add every card to your list.

  3. Send us your cards

    Mail them in or bring them by, whichever we take. When they arrive we check each card against your list and pay your quote. If a card’s condition or count is different, we adjust that card’s price.